Time pressure pervades many contexts, with well-studied performance impacts. However, individuals’ subjective experiences of time pressure may be separable from, and relate to outcomes independently of, objective performance metrics. Despite this possibility, prior research often fails to investigate or account for individual differences in the subjective experience of time pressure, likely due to the lack of an appropriate measurement instrument. Here, we develop (Study 1) and validate (Study 2) the Time Pressure Experience Scale (TPES), which measures the cognitive and affective experiences of time pressure (as two 10-item subscales). In Study 1, we identified the factor structure of subjective time pressure experiences, with which we scaffolded construction of the TPES. In Study 2, we replicated this structure in an independent sample and demonstrated strong internal validity metrics. Study 2 also externally validated the TPES using a novel metric: Each TPES subscale predicted corresponding cognitive/affective ratings made immediately after completing a mildly challenging arithmetic task under time pressure. Crucially, we utilized increasingly strict tests by cumulatively controlling for cognitive/affective ratings made after completion of the task without time pressure, the other TPES subscale, and objective arithmetic task performance. Even with the strictest controls, the cognitive and affective subscales uniquely predicted relevant time-pressure-specific subjective experiences. The persistence of these results while controlling for objective performance demonstrates the added theoretical value of examining subjective experiences related to time pressure. In sum, we offer the TPES as a useful tool to support research related to individual differences in the subjective experience of time pressure.