This chapter offers a comparative-historical analysis of two green intentional communities—Tamera (Portugal, founded 1994) and Monte Verità (Switzerland, 1900–1926)—to examine how cultural innovation operates as a form of soft power. Extending Joseph Nye’s concept, it introduces post-patriarchal soft power: a mode of influence rooted in embodied practices, ethical charisma, and aesthetic dissent from industrial modernity. Drawing on ethnographic and archival research, the chapter shows how both communities mobilised symbolic appeals to ecological regeneration, emotional transparency, and sexual liberation to secure resources and legitimacy in the absence of supportive institutional frameworks. However, these mechanisms of attraction also generated exclusion. Participation privileged culturally mobile and economically secure actors, while linguistic norms and economically demanding initiation periods limited access. The chapter argues that, without institutionally supported strategies for promoting access by less privileged social groups, countercultural experiments risk becoming symbolically influential yet socially selective enclaves.