Background Internalizing psychopathology is thought to be characterized by excessive responding to negative stimuli. Measuring this in the lab – e.g., via amygdala response and emotion ratings elicited by pictures – can provide insight into in-the-moment, time-limited emotional response in a controlled environment. Ecological momentary assessment (EMA) of everyday emotional experience can provide complementary measurement of emotion dynamics in response to real-world stimuli and events. When used together, these lab-based and everyday emotional assessments may account for additional variance in the development and worsening of psychopathology. Methods Seventy-five participants with mixed internalizing symptoms (50 female, 24 male, 1 other) were recruited from the community. fMRI BOLD signal and subjective valence ratings were acquired while participants viewed emotional pictures. Affective inertia for negative affect (NA) and positive affect (PA) was calculated using multilevel modeling of EMA data collected in participants’ daily lives. Internalizing symptoms were assessed at study entry and one year later. We tested how fMRI amygdala BOLD, picture ratings, and their interaction with affective inertia would predict internalizing symptoms one year later. Results In individuals with higher NA inertia only, greater negative > neutral fMRI BOLD and negative picture valence ratings predicted increases in internalizing symptom severity one year later. Hierarchical regression analyses further demonstrated that neural and subjective measures accounted for unique variance in symptom change. No significant results emerged for PA. Conclusions Individuals with heightened negative emotional reactivity for whom everyday negative emotion is also resistant to internal and external change may be at risk for increasing internalizing psychopathology.