People in depression tend to retrieve overly general memories instead of specific events (Overgeneral Memory, Williams et al., 2007). The most commonly used measures in overgeneral memory (OGM) research, the Autobiographical Memory Test (AMT), consists of five positive and five negative cue words. OGM studies often fail to find differences in specificity between positive and negative cues and this could partly result from a methodological issue. An examination of 61 studies using AMT revealed that more than 85 cues were chosen without using a standardized selection method. We explored the characteristics of these AMT cues used in OGM research. Forty university students (20 female) rated the cues for valence, arousal and dominance and filled out depression measures. We found that valence, arousal and dominance ratings were modulated by participants’ depression level. Our results suggest a strong need to have a standardized selection method for words used in OGM research.