Leadership is socially constructed by both the actions and reactions of leaders and followers. Here we examine how followers’ attributes both commonly and uniquely influence the ratings of transformational and ethical leadership, including in our assessment, follower identity (i.e., individual, relational, and collective identities), affectivity (i.e., positive and negative), and goal-orientation (i.e., promotion and prevention focus). Our results from a sample of 262 Army squads (total of 1,587 squad members) show that positive affectivity and relational identity were positively associated with both transformational and ethical leadership. Promotion focus and collective identity was positively associated with transformational leadership, while negative affectivity was negatively associated with ethical leadership. In additional supplementary analyses, we further examined the extent to which each of the follower attributes was associated with the general factor score (or common variance) between transformational and ethical leadership and with the specific factor scores (or unique variance) for each leadership style. The implications from these findings suggest that both the conceptualization and operationalization of leadership should incorporate how followers’ individual differences drive their unique perceptions of leadership.