Were the Beatles slipping creatively as 1967 dawned? A swelling chorus of critics and fans were saying so (Aspinall, “Real”). The Beatles' recording of “Strawberry Fields Forever,” one of their most peculiar (see Mellers) but nonetheless popular song-recordings, had been designed for inclusion in their Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band album. But, disappointed by the lukewarm critical reception and unimpressive sales of their previous 1p and keen to prove they still had their creative “chops,” the Beatles authorized the release of the song as a single. Released February 13, 1967 it was in the Top 40 for seven weeks, entering on March 11, 1967, peaking at No. 8“ (Dowlding 149). “Strawberry Fields Forever” (SFF) has been widely recognized as a departure from the love songs that first triggered the group's popularity (see, e. g., Mellers, Coleman, MacDonald). “It was a landmark song in its day,” a Chicago radio station program director (Station #4) said in a more recent (April 1996) interview conducted for this study. “And it's managed to hang on ever since.” More than 33 years later SFF can still be heard on radio stations across the nation. Other popular music acts, such as Richie Havens, Blur, and Candyflip, have recorded it. Close to the apartment building where Lennon was murdered, the people of the City of New York have dedicated a section of Central Park to his memory. They call it “Strawberry Fields.” Las Vegas, NV, boasts a Strawberry Fields Counseling Center. And in 1994 Beatles' recordings producer George Martin proclaimed SFF the “most original and inventive track [made] to date in pop music” (24). These facts alone warrant inquiry into the constituents of SFF's lasting popularity. A Dartmouth musicologist reminds us that music has no power to “simply inflict its meanings upon helpless” listeners. Rather, “texts become popular when people find them meaningful in the contexts of their own lives” (Walser 150). In this light an inquiry into SFF's lasting popularity may be best construed as a search to discover what meanings listeners have made of it. As I argued elsewhere (“Song” 71), neither popular culture nor mass communication research has developed to the point where either theoreticians or mass communicators are able to predict which texts will remain popular. Television news historian David Culbert found “no set of principles…which would enable someone to predict which television stories will be visually and historically” enduring (141). Similarly, popular music research offers no principles which would enable someone to predict which song-recordings will endure (see e. g., Chambers; Chappie and Garofalo; Frith, Sound; Gillett; Hirsch; Palmer; and Peterson and Berger). Explanation, however, can be as theoretically worthy as prediction. But to date neither popular culture nor mass communication nor popular music research has explained the appeal of Beatles music for audiences today. To be sure communication researchers as diverse in orientation as Marxist-postmodernist Lawrence Grossberg (“Politics,” “Another,” “If Rock,” “Is There,” “Reply”) and content analysts Christenson; Cooper; Chesebro, Fougler, Nachman, and Yannelli; and Fedler, Hall, and Tanzi have attempted to account for the popularity of popular music. But neither they nor the popular music scholars cited above have asked, let alone answered, “What precisely accounts for the lasting appeal of an enduringly popular musical text?” While [fellow Beatle songsmith] Paul McCartney's gift lay in composing love songs, John [Lennon] was incapable of songwriting [solely] as a craftsman, “for other people.” Conversely, the extrovert McCartney found it hard to write about himself. In that, John Lennon excelled…From “Strawberry Fields Forever” through to “Imagine,” John Lennon's work, in and out of the Beatles, was distinct [from songs such as “She Loves You”] and highly personalized…For although he loved the speed of rock ‘n’ roll, his own writing would have to act as a mirror of his personality as he grew older and more observant and wanted more from life than teenagers screaming his name. At twenty-six, John wanted his music to express the important things in his life; his childhood memories; his assiduous reading of newspapers and magazines; his love of words and sharp observation of unexpected phrase; [and] his own frailties and rejection of the tough-guy Beatles image (115; order inverted for the sake of quotation). “Interaction” is a term one critic has used to refer to an unconventionality audible in some popular musical communication: addressing listeners personally through the use of the second person (see Williams). Conventionally, rock lyrics are first person narratives (Van Der Horst 48). Indeed, for novelist E. L. Doctorow, “All songs are [conventionally again] songs of justification” (61). Lennon's use of the second person in SFF not only addresses listeners directly but cloaks any glaring self-justification in the lyrics. The use of the second person endows SFF with the quality Williams (19) calls “interaction,” the inclusion in the recorded song of “a you” (1) who is sung about, (2) whose presence is invoked by the song narrator, and (3) with whom the song narrator “interact[s].” Among the innovations audible in the production of SFF are the Beatles' inaugural use of (1) mellotron, a keyboard instrument that sounds like harmonizing flutes when chorded; (2) deliberate electronic distortion in the recording of a vocal performance, and (3) orchestral accompaniment in the recording of song penned primarily by Lennon. Each of these inventive features will be examined in greater detail. A critic reminds us that music can serve as a communication medium through which “dreams” and fantasies “are unveiled, souls exorcised, tensions canalized, strength realized'” (Johnson, qtd. in Frith, Performing 88). SFF was Lennon's first attempt to use the medium of Beatles music as a means to unveil or exorcise aspects of, express tensions about or realize strengths of his childhood: Strawberry Field (Lennon added the “s”) was the name of a real Salvation Army hostel in Lennon's hometown of Liverpool. For long-time Lennon friend and biographer Coleman the “words 'Strawberry Fields Forever' signify John's wish for an eternal childhood, where he could remain innocent and happy… John enjoyed his childhood memories. [They reminded him of] an era of simplicity when he…was happy” (Coleman 116; order inverted for the sake of quotation). Similarly but more abstractly an adult respondent who had just begun a university teaching career in 1967 said the lyrics' “imagery” evokes a “Garden of Eden.” Everett contends SFF's lyrics illustrate the latter two categories of Beatle commemoration: They may be read as a recollection of the painful time in Lennon's childhood that he passed in an orphanage. But, Everett argues, by marking (thrice over) “Strawberry Fields” as a haven where “there's nothing to get hung about,” Lennon sentimentalizes—or, to coin a term, roseates—what were more likely to have been grim years. The very phrase “Strawberry Fields,” the recording's producer wrote, “evoke[s] a sunny meadow in shimmery warm sunshine, where you can drift and dream in a wonderful limbo” (Martin 14). For a Midwestern adult who was attending university when the song was released, SFF depicts “a fantasy world.” Consistent with this, the very color of the strawberry; the “red, red” (Shakespeare) of the rose; fosters this sentimentalization. “In reality” the real Strawberry Field “was hardly the stuff of romance” (14). Psychoanalytic literary theory provides another lens through which Lennon's lyrics may be viewed, a lens that magnifies Martin's and Everett's observations about them. According to literary theorists who subscribe to many schools of criticism that have been called psychoanalytic, the very act of writing is an attempt to bridge. To lyricize, writes Claridge, is to both confront desire and to defer it, or alternately, to build a span that joins the “is” to the “desired,” the “ego” to “reality” (Schapiro xii). In this context SFF may be heard as Lennon's attempt to construct such a bridge; the lyric, “It's getting hard to be someone,” both confronts the narrator's painful present and, at the same time, defers complete realization of any wish he may harbor for relief. Even more, the line links the expressed wish for a separate, integral identity —“to be someone”— to reality's resistance to the formation of such an identity. The lyrics enounce other binary oppositions, but I shall confine myself to noting only one other: “All” is invoked three times in the song, “nothing” four. Elsewhere I argued that the lasting popularity of a song-recording released later in 1967 may be traced in part to its character as “mythic discourse” (“Notes” 39). After Campbell, myth may be “defined…not as apocryphal stories associated with earlier cultures but as vital contemporary creators of meaning and value” (335; see also Silverstone, Rushing): Myths “mediate”—or bridge—real oppositions in their host culture (Campbell 335, citing Levi-Strauss). That is to say myths both express and fictionally resolve them (see Rushing, Silverstone). “Life and death, good and evil,…nature and culture,…individual and institution, the abstract and concrete, presence and absence,…normalcy and deviance,” the familiar and the strange, the real and the artificial, safety and danger, “tradition [and] change,…the personal and [the] social,” and mythic texts and the realities they claim to “represent” are among the oppositions myths mediate (Campbell 335-36, 341-42, 346, 352, 358, 361; see also Silverstone). SFF enounces its mythic character linguistically in its first verse line, “Living is easy with eyes closed.” Here life (“living”) is plausibly joined to death, the lifeless body “with eyes closed.” A related “core…concern and deep anxiet[y]” contemporary myth mediates (Silverstone 23) is “a yearning for wholeness” (Rushing 188) in the face of what Rushing takes to be the corresponding—and, in our time, pervasive—fear of permanent “separation from self, society, and the universe” (189). Lennon himself maintained SFF expressed the loneliness he felt in his childhood: “ ‘Nobody seems to be as hip as me’ is what I was saying. 'Therefore, I must be crazy or a genius' ” (qtd. in Dowlding 148). In the light of mythic criticism and Lennon's gloss consider again verse 2: “No one I think is in my tree/I mean it must be high or low.” Here the loneliness, the anxiety, and, arguably, the arrogance of Lennon's subjective reflections on his childhood (in his aforementioned comment on SFF) are transcoded, metaphorized: “In my tree” both stands in for and transcends—ambiguates—the more straightforwardly declarative “hip as me.” This commutation arguably invites listeners such as a radio station music director interviewed for this study to first identify the line as denoting “loneliness” and then to identify with Lennon as one who experienced a loneliness with which the radio executive can connotatively identify, even re-experience. Similarly, “high or low” both stands in for and ambiguates “crazy or a genius.” Indeed, which of the two did Lennon consider “high” and which “low?” In her inquiry into the lasting popularity of another popular culture text; the film, E.T., Rushing insists that all “statements expressing the[is] contemporary sense of fragmentation and the corresponding impulse toward unity are of considerable rhetorical [and cultural] significance” (189). Heard as a mediation of, or meditation on, such hopes or “yearning[s,] for wholeness” (188) and such fears of permanent “separation from self, society and the universe” (189), SFF is, like E.T., an expression of “mythic transcendence” (189). In sum, SFF, “a study [of] uncertain identity, tinged with the loneliness of solitary rebel[lion] against all things institutional [and simultaneously,] an eerie longing for a childhood of hide-and-seek and tree-climbing” (MacDonald 173), endures, again in part, because it retains its communicative and cultural power to serve a variety of audiences as mythic discourse. For a program director of a radio station in a populous city or market, the song's “longing for childhood…is something everyone can relate to, which probably explains its lasting power.” The following section builds on this introductory analysis by considering SFF's textuality in a way that echoes its organization. An analysis that develops its arguments by reproducing the organization of the text it analyzes may have any number of advantages over alternatives that develop arguments otherwise. A fact about the SFF's production supports this study's rhetorical choice: The version of SFF that Lennon first brought to the recording studio did not start with the chorus—as the song-recording released did. (The early version began with the first verse line: “Living is easy with eyes closed.”) Martin reports, however, that Lennon voiced qualms about starting the song with a negative thought. Attuned to the syntagmatic dimension of verse, even if he never called it that. Lennon composed an alternative, the chorus. For Martin. “‘Let me take you down, ‘cos I'm going to Strawberry Fields' was a good move, because the lyric now immediately seized you[, the auditor,] by the throat. The song made you share an intriguing journey, instead of beginning with an abstract comment” (17). In the words of an adult respondent interviewed for this study, the song “suggests Paradise.” My attempt to craft an analysis of SFF that echoes its organization is simply my way, in Rushing's phrase, of “approaching” SFF “with proper respect” (“Mythic” 267). Indeed, semotician Jurij Lotman reminds us that “the choice of a particular form of text organization is directly meaningful for the entire quantity of transmitted information” (67). Verse 1: For Everett, the lyrics, “Living is easy with eyes closed, misunderstanding all you see…It's getting hard to be someone” are best read as Lennon self-disclosures: “It's getting hard to be someone” reveals a Lennon who, as has been suggested, hurts. Supporting this reading is Lennon's own claim that of all his Beatles compositions, only two were personally “honest”: “Help!” and SFF (Dowlding 180; Martin 18). Not dissimilarly Mellers takes SFF as illustrative of the period of Beatles creativity he lauds as “mature” (104). However this may be, the anxiety-cum-loneliness of “It's getting hard to be someone” gives way to the declaration, “But it all works out/It doesn't matter much to me.” For Everett such declarations help the himself from and express at The of “Strawberry Fields” the same These arguments are But with the lens of the the “But it all works out/It doesn't matter much to may not be best read as a of as a that a painful “is” with a (Schapiro xii). can the relief. But the as a in a phrase, that other such as can the same Verse 2: The song's from anxiety-cum-loneliness to or is The loneliness that “no the that no one gives way to it's all is I think it's not Similarly, verse you I and it's a the same or relief. other aspects of SFF it to say now that the has that the of SFF is study supports the that SFF's popularity from its not so much earlier Beatles songs earlier in of in songs released in the to period is in his that lyrics a fantasy in which and become analysis of his reveals that songs released the of the Beatles' a of love in Beatles songs, however, were of many of the and on in previous In this light SFF not only of Beatles' (see but as a of song and, to the of the song's lyrics in the way they call the and of a of people and you words used out of in and and all over the The is a again to John's song, and you will this The SFF's because it a had the Beatles used both in a other A musicologist reminds us that a lyric can to by from songwriting the craft of songwriting in as a qtd. in Frith, For critic the of SFF's lyrics in their attempt to express the to or personal to A of SFF's in the and of its production to previous songs the Beatles production of SFF was more The Beatles' first one to and in studio time and Sgt. Lonely Hearts Club for which SFF was to and The Beatles recorded of SFF alone and I the innovations audible in the production of SFF as the Beatles' inaugural use of (1) mellotron, a keyboard instrument that sounds like harmonizing flutes when chorded; (2) deliberate electronic distortion in the recording of a vocal performance, and (3) orchestral accompaniment in the recording of song penned primarily by Lennon. I shall of these inventive features in greater SFF the Beatles' inaugural use of the song-recording with from the instrument At the time he was recording the song, Lennon called the by (Martin But Lennon was not with his track and Martin to it Martin this by the on Lennon's This had the of Lennon's and more and (17). for the first time, Lennon Martin to orchestral accompaniment for a song he The was a Beatles song of the first use of the mellotron, the first a Beatle vocal had been and the first time orchestral in a Lennon production that SFF's from both Lennon's and Martin's To the the song seems to be a But the release was a of two Lennon had and to Martin found the of the two to because the two takes were not in the same nor But he and to even the on which the were recorded to the take in the to the one in the The one into the song, but it is to most listeners. For has out like a But to The Beatles had recorded takes of the song, and the release of and This may not be a of the of the but it is a of it nonetheless and, I as much a of its popularity as any I not sure much analysis has to with for a of is a like in if is the or The power to to or to or is the call on the is the most of all the the Beatles' particular of what Rushing the of the the music and then one are and Martin was for of in to the studio and found the Beatles something from a very John and Paul were George was on it was to the with his this, no other rock to such in their SFF not only the Beatles' way of music but also or the recording of SFF was the first of Beatles songs Lennon penned that were and into his and the content of The SFF was a Beatles a “a of things to an expression of both matter and a of