This study investigates customers’ responses to the phrase, How do you like your cereal?, a question posed by servers at a cereal cafe. This phrase, along with several variants, abrogates linguistic service encounter norms, and customer response type is heavily influenced by the type and content of the servers’ questions. The data indicate that certain types of questions encourage direct orders from customers, whereas other questions, namely How do you like your cereal?, provoke disfluencies and confusion among customers. An analysis of how the questions violate linguistic norms is given, along with why customers interpret some questions as requests for information and others as ordering prompts.